Simons and Masschelein 10 (Maarten and Jan, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences at Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, “Governmental, Political, and Pedagogical Subjectification: Foucault with Ranciere,” Educational Philosophy and Theory, Volume 42, Issue 5-6, August)
"The defence and promotion of democracy..... more detail what is at stake."
Their plan results in a propagation of Democratic Biopolitics to the Arab World
Sobe 07 (Sobe, W. Noah. Loyola University Chicago "An historical perspective on coordinating education post-conflict: Biopolitics, Governing at a distance, and States of Exception" Comparative Education Vol.9 (2007). Print.)
At an inescapable level..... and international co-operation.
Democracy takes hold of us as Citizens and thus enables biopolitical control
Sauer 05 (Sauer-Thompson, Gary, Professor of Philosophy at The Flinders University of South Australia, “Democracy as Governmentality,” www.sauer thompson.com /archives/philosophy /0027 98. html )
Ali does not mention citizenship...for governing through citizenship.
Biopolitical control culminates in extinction
Bell 05 (Biopolitical Strategies of Security: ions on Canada’s New National Security Policy Colleen Bell Doctoral Candidate Department of Political Science York University YCISS Working Paper Number March 2005)
The ‘invitation’ for ‘diverse communities’ to participate.....citizens, democrats, or even humans.”
The Alternative is: the judge should vote negative to reject the affirmative’s biopolitical assistance and in doing so open up a space for resistance, criticizing the problematic discourse of the 1AC enables this
Hayden 99 (Sara. Associate Professor of Communication Studies at The University of Montana, WOMEN'SSTUDIES IN COMMUNITY, Spring 1999, p. 30)
In his early writings, Foucault....we can "modify its hold.”